Gerry Donohue is an established author of books and magazine articles spanning a wide variety of topics. Stop Losing Points: 50 Mistakes Recreational Tennis Players Make — and How to Fix Them is his third tennis book. Since I already reviewed his previous two offerings in this category, Winning Doubles Strategy and Winning Singles Strategy, I approached this newest work with the expectation that he would continue to expound on the philosophy that recreational players improve faster through better decisions than through better strokes. That’s exactly what Donohue did, albeit with a subtle but meaningful twist. As the title suggests, rather than focusing primarily on how to win more points, this book explores how tennis players can stop giving so many points away.
Donohue opens with a premise that will sound familiar to experienced competitors but is often overlooked at the recreational level. Tennis is fundamentally a game of mistakes. Most points do not end with spectacular winners. They end because someone eventually misses. Matches are won less by producing brilliant shots than by consistently making fewer poor decisions.
One surprise for me was the amount of technical advice contained in this book. Given Donohue’s longstanding emphasis on strategy over mechanics, I expected another largely tactical discussion. Instead, he begins with stroke integrity and clean contact. Rather than contradicting his previous philosophy, this feels like an acknowledgment that good strategy still depends on reasonably dependable execution. Donohue also shares stories from his own playing experiences throughout the book, which helps illustrate the ideas and make them feel accessible rather than theoretical.
The sections on movement, recovery, and court positioning are classic Donohue. He has always demonstrated an intuitive understanding of court geometry, and it remains one of his greatest strengths as a tennis writer. One observation that particularly resonated with me is that most points are actually lost between shots. Poor recovery, inefficient movement, and subtle positioning mistakes often undermine the next ball long before it is struck. His discussion of split-step timing reinforces that same idea. Good footwork is not simply about speed. It is about consistently arriving in positions that allow better decisions to follow.
Donohue also includes a number of awareness drills that require little technical complexity yet can improve how players think about the game. Several struck me as exercises that could even serve as effective mid-point reset mechanisms during matches. Those practical, immediately actionable ideas remain one of the defining characteristics of Donohue’s writing.
The middle portion of the book, covering rally tolerance, margin management, point construction, and opponent awareness, is where I believe Donohue is at his absolute best. This is what smart, intentional tennis looks like. Rather than chasing low-percentage winners, he repeatedly emphasizes making sound decisions, maintaining depth, understanding patterns, and constructing points that gradually increase pressure. His discussion of return positioning also deserves particular mention. Recreational players often default to standing in the same location regardless of opponent or situation. Donohue encourages readers to think much more intentionally about where they position themselves before the server ever strikes the ball.
As with Donohue’s previous books, I occasionally found myself mentally pushing back when practical rules of thumb were presented as universal truths. For example, his advice against attempting offensive shots from a defensive position is excellent guidance for the overwhelming majority of players. At higher levels, however, exceptional athletes can sometimes create offense from seemingly impossible situations. Similarly, his recommendations regarding defensive court positioning are broadly correct, but there are certainly circumstances where his rules of thumb represent a more nuanced trade-off than implied. These observations do not diminish the value of the book. They simply reinforce what I concluded in my previous reviews. Donohue’s recommendations are outstanding rules of thumb, even if advanced players occasionally find justified exceptions.
Some chapters resonated with me on a more personal level. His discussion of closing on the net after an approach shot felt uncomfortably relevant because it identified one of the biggest weaknesses currently affecting my own game. His diagnosis was accurate enough that I have no intention of sharing those precise details publicly, as they would fall under the category of competitive intelligence.
The serve chapter also contains ideas that I expect to spend considerable time exploring. The concept of developing a “Second Serve Identity” is one of the more thought-provoking ideas in the entire book. Likewise, his reminder that great returners are rarely trying to end the point immediately but rather working to dictate the server’s next shot reflects the broader philosophy underlying the entire work: Have a plan. Apply pressure patiently. Make the next decision a good one.
The closing chapters shift toward competitive composure and momentum management. Even here, Donohue avoids the vague motivational language that often dominates tennis psychology. His mindset advice remains grounded in specific behaviors and practical habits rather than abstract confidence-building exercises. That action-oriented approach appealed to me.
Stop Losing Points: 50 Mistakes Recreational Tennis Players Make — and How to Fix Them feels like the natural culmination of Donohue’s three tennis books. The earlier volumes taught recreational players how to think more strategically in singles and doubles. This one steps back even further, arguing that the fastest path to improvement is often to eliminate the self-inflicted mistakes that keep players from winning matches.
Gerry Donohue continues to remind us that for most recreational players, better decisions will often produce positive results much sooner.
Fiend At Court participates in the Amazon Associates program and receives a paid commission on any purchases made via the links in this article. Details on the disposition of proceeds are available on the “About Fiend at Court” page.
